A rising number of women and girls are leaving South Asian nations such as Nepal, India and Pakistan to work in Bollywood-style dance bars in Kenya’s adult entertainment industry – many illegally – according to anti-trafficking activists and police.
There is no official data on the numbers but the results of police raids, combined with figures on repatriation of rescued women, suggest scores of women and underage girls are victims of organised human trafficking from South Asia to Kenya.
Latest figures from Nepal’s National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) showed 43 women and girls were repatriated from dance bars in Kenya and neighboring Tanzania in 2016/17. There were no comparison numbers available.
To date there have been few prosecutions to raise awareness about what authorities fear is a growing trend, but April’s rescue and subsequent arrest threw a spotlight on the issue.
SPOTLIGHT ON RISING TREND
The owner of the Mombasa club, Asif Amirali Alibhai Jetha, was charged with three counts of human trafficking, accused of harboring victims for the purpose of deception, using premises to promote trafficking, and confiscation of passports.
The Canadian-British national denied the charges in court, pleading not guilty, saying the women were in Kenya of their own consent and legally employed as cultural dancers at a business with no erotic dancing or sexual exploitation.
He is currently on bail awaiting the next court hearing with no date yet set.
Common in India, so-called mujra dance bars – where young women dance to Bollywood music for money from male patrons – have mushroomed in cities including Nairobi, Mombasa and Kisumu, where there are countless Kenyans of South Asian descent.
Police and anti-trafficking groups have repeatedly voiced concerns that some of these private clubs are used as a front to ensnare women and girls, some in sex slavery, with women forced to pay off loans by erotic dancing or having sex with clients.
Nepali beautician Sheela didn’t think twice about ditching her salon job when she received a call offering seven times her salary to work as a cultural dancer at a nightclub in Kenya.
It didn’t matter that the 23-year-old woman from a village in the Himalayan foothills had never heard of the east African nation. Or that she had no experience as a dancer, had never met the owner of the club, and was not shown an employment contract.
With elderly parents to care for and medical bills to clear after her brother suffered a motorbike accident, the offer of 60,000 Kenyan shillings ($600) monthly, with food, housing and transport costs all covered, was a no-brainer for Sheela.
“(But) it was not what I expected,” said Sheela, who was rescued with 11 other Nepali women from a nightclub in Kenya’s coastal city of Mombasa in April where she danced on stage from 9 p.m. to 4 a.m. getting tips from male clients.
“I was told that being escorted everywhere by the driver, not leaving the flat except for work, and not having my passport or phone, was for my safety,” added Sheela, who did not want to give her real name, at a safe house in Mombasa’s Shanzu suburb.
Sheela and the other women rescued from the Mombasa club told the Thomson Reuters Foundation they had not been forced to have sex with customers.
Anita Nyanjong, a lawyer for human rights group Equality Now, said it was hard to get to the truth as survivors of trafficking often would not admit what had happened.
“Most victims come from poor conservative families and there is shame and stigma attached to this kind of thing,” she said.
“Even though victims may have been forced or duped into sex work, they may be convinced by traffickers not to speak … told they will be arrested for prostitution if they admit it.”
In Kenya, many local women and girls are promised good jobs only to be enslaved in domestic servitude or forced into prostitution – often in the sex tourism industry.
Kenya is home to about 328,000 modern-day slaves – about 1 in 143 of its population – according to the Global Slavery Index by the Walk Free Foundation, an Australia-based rights group.
But in recent years police raids on mujra bars – named after a traditional Asian dance – uncovered organized human trafficking from South Asia to Kenya, a trend highlighted by the United States in its annual Trafficking in Persons (TIP) report.
“The raids have helped us understand the modus operandi of traffickers in Kenya who have agents overseas to recruit women for them,” an official from Kenya’s Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) said on condition of anonymity.
“They are offered jobs as cultural dancers and given around one month’s salary in advance. But when they arrive, their movements are restricted and they have to do erotic and sexually explicit dancing – and often have to have sex with clients.”
Such victims enter Kenya either on a three-month tourist visa on arrival for south Asians, or on a special temporary work permit for cultural performers, according to the DCI official.
Sheela and the other 11 women rescued in Mombasa said they had come to Kenya separately over the past nine months on flights through India and Ethiopia arranged by the club owner.
In court testimonies the women, aged 16 to 34, said they were told to carry hand luggage only and tell immigration officials they were visiting friends or family in Kenya.
The women worked every night, were given stage names, and were expected to earn about $4,000 each per month in tips.
“We didn’t get the tips as they were for the boss,” said Meena, 20, who did not want to give her real name. “But the top performing girls would get bonuses of 20,000 shillings ($200), 30,000 ($300), and 50,000 ($500) if they met their targets.”
The women told the court their passports were taken and they did not know the location of the club or their accommodation.
Paul Adhoch, head of Trace Kenya, a charity that provided shelter to the group of 12, said the women did not identify as victims but their treatment suggested otherwise.
“The way they were deceptively recruited, the under-the-radar manner in which they were brought into Kenya, restrictions on their freedoms and movements, their passports being taken – are all clear signs of human trafficking,” he said.
The women were repatriated to Nepal in July.
“This whole thing has been terrible,” said Sonia, 24, who did want to give her real name, the day before she left.
“I should never have come – it was a mistake. All I want to do is go home. I never come to Kenya again.”